Blog

Would you take this rook?

Black to move. White has just played 23. Rae1, putting a rook directly in front of Black's rook on e8 with nothing in between.

You can take it. What would White play next?

Black to move after 23. Rae1. White's rook on e1 and Black's rook on e8 are highlighted; the continuation is not shown.
Think about it before reading on. Look for White's reply after 23...Rxe1, and remember that White doesn't have to recapture.

This position comes from a development match between Feint (White) and a strength-limited version of Stockfish (Black).

The wrong end of the board

In the game, Black took the rook.

After 23...Rxe1, the obvious move for White is to recapture with the rook on f1. Most of us would look there first: a piece has just been taken, so you take one back.

White played 24. Qb8+ instead.

After 23...Rxe1 24.Qb8+, White's queen checks along the eighth rank. Black's king is boxed in by its own pawns.
The rook on e1 has won material, but the king on g8 has bigger problems.

The queen now gives check along the eighth rank. Black's king is hemmed in by its own pawns on f7 and g7, and White's bishop covers h7, so the king can't move. Nothing can capture the queen either.

That leaves Black exactly two legal moves, and both are blocks. One is 24...Re8, bringing back the rook that just captured, and White mates with 25. Qxe8#.

The game went the slightly longer way:

23... Rxe1
24. Qb8+ Rd8
25. Qxd8+ Re8
26. Qxe8#

First the rook on d5 drops back to d8 to block the check, and White takes it. Then the rook on e1 returns to e8 to block again, and White takes that one too. Each rook blocks one check, and each is captured.

Final position after 26.Qxe8 checkmate. The white queen on e8 is highlighted beside the black king on g8.

A sacrifice, with a catch

Normally this is where the Reveal comes in and we show what our human-prediction model was up to. This time we have to own up: the model can't take credit for the trap. Feint already knew it was winning comfortably, so its 'trickiness' reward had switched off automatically. It wasn't trying to set a trap. It simply played the strongest engine move.

Black was in trouble either way. Declining the rook would still have left a large disadvantage, but taking it allowed Qb8+ and a forced mate.

The position is still a good reminder not to recapture on autopilot. Before you take back, check whether another piece has something better to do. Here the rook on f1 never had to move.

You can download the full game as a PGN, or set up the position for a friend and see how quickly they grab the rook.